There has been times where it is wrong, the commentary doesn’t acknowledge it as wrong so this tells me it’s a mistake in the actual game and not for realism. If Alan Smith said “ohhh thats a poor decision” then fine, I would just complain about it like I did with the “penalties” topic in this article.

Another mistake in offsides I often see is when you tackle a player and the ball rolls towards one of your players who is ahead of all the opposition players on the park. But yet it still counts it as offside, as if I’ve passed the ball to him.

It even tries to show a replay but it cuts back to the actual game really quickly (probably because it doesn’t know how to show why it was offside)