I haven't played the game and if I did I might think it's worthy of a 2, who knows

all I'm trying to convey is that Rich's "opinion" is that the game is a 10, and a 10 doesn't mean "perfect"

if you wanna believe that Rich is a fanboy that's on you, I haven't told you to think otherwise… I'm just trying to help you out by giving you a few pointers on what a 10 means

all I wanna know is how did you get 100% of the trophies in that Japanese cats-telling-the-news game

did you honestly spend 6 hours tapping the X button?

This isn't about the score , read the words the dude typed it was all fanboyish trash. Didn't he come mad late into the Podcast after overdosing on the DLC?, lol this dude was hooked on it like a crack fiend.

Then you read the review and you can notice that!, so of course he is going to type that type of review and then have the nerve to give that a 10? come on now, if that doesn't say crack fiend bullshit review then you're not understanding the situation.

A review is not suppose to be a fucking opinion, it supposed to inform people about the game and all that, if in any way( scores/ words ) fanboyish attitude is detected then the review is flat out trash.

a review is ultimately an opinion though

if you want info about the game visit the games official website or check the back of the box

That's what separates reviewers with a lemmings type attitude from no fear of being criticize, they will give the game getting 10s everywhere a 9.3 or below.

Uh, see that is your problem son, you shouldn't be reviewing this game since you just told me you're a GTA fanboy, I not going to type reviews for games I am a fanboy off, that makes no sense at all since it will be automatic 10/10( lol you proved that ).

When you type a review you shouldn't think of it as typing an opinion, you're doing a review, you're informing people about the game, their is no need to show your fanboyish love for it in any way, once you do that it isn't a review.

Take the criticism and don't get mad, I am just keeping it 100 with you.

I could give a DS game a 9 but then give a PS3 game a 8, it doesn't necessarily mean that the DS game is better, it could just mean the DS game is better value for money or it might stand out more compared to other games that are on the DS

At the end of the day FUCK the score, read the text…

Reviews are tough politics man, one game gets a 9 ot 10 by someone else, and then you feel like you HAVE to give this other game a 10 becase you feel its better than the game they reviewed. Its tough politics, I actually regret my resistance score a lil now, but at that time I actually felt like it was the hottest shit ever…but as time goes on new hot games keep dropping that are way hotter than last years ones.

I agree that i didnt expect this game (gta episodes) to get a 10/10, but if the reviewer feels its that hot then he's in that position to. his job is to let everyone know how hot it is based on that scale, and then they can assess whether they wish to buy it.

its hard, but yeah. eventually we may have to discuss as a group the scores we give on games, just so the whole team is on an understanding. I know for a fact that the team dont agree with some of my scores, but heck the majority of the team agreed on the uncharted one.

No matter how you cut it Joekilla you can't deny there is at least one game out there that your a fan of. With that said I leave you to ponder over that thought. Thanks for your critical feedback and clearly it should be used to better define your argument.If you feel so strongly write a review yourself and show me how its done. PEACE

Son its a Fanboyish review, I can say the same for Uncharted 2's review here by Swiff or H-Towns ODST review, all perspectives of people who prefer a specific console, lets be real here, they all got the same fanboy treatment.

But the main point is neither of these games out there are 10s, no game deserves that in gaming period because no game is perfect.

Richard you're not reviewing VALUE here man, you're reviewing a bunch of DLC game, you could had added "VALUE-10" if you wanted value to get some shine.